Verzamelen algemeen/Rarity list: Robbedoes

Wat ik nog altijd mis is wat verzamelaars info. Daarom deze poging :

Uit de gegevens van Catawiki (Te Koop, Gezocht, In Verzameling) heb ik deze gedistilleeerd (Alleen Franquin) :

Je hebt 3 reeksen:

- De twee oudste 'vierkante hardcovers' zoals deze . Zeldzaam, maar toch redelijk als je de nodige euro's hebt.

- De 'rechthoekige hardcovers': hier zijn er drie echt moeilijke met de notoire Zwarte Hoeden , 

- De softcovers, waarbij het opmerkelijk is dat de oudere (jaren 50) zoals De horen van de neushoren couranter zijn dan de recentere (begin jaren '60) zoals De gorilla heeft het gedaan . En dan heb je nog Het nest van de Marsupilami's waarover JozefK ook al wat over gezegd heeft.

Tenslotte dient ook nog vermeld dat er van De roof van de Marsupilami en Robbedoes en de Erfgenamen twee versies gekend zijn:
- Met 'leren' rug en verkleuring tengevolge van vislijm: Roof en Erfgenamen
- Met 'linen' rug zonder verkleuring: Roof en Erfgenamen
De geschiedenis hierachter is nog onduidelijk.

What I still miss is some collector info. So this attempt:

From the data of Catawiki (For Sale, Wanted, In Collection) I have distilled this (Franquin only) :

You have 3 sets:

- The two oldest 'square hardcovers' like this one. Rare, but still reasonable if you have the necessary euros.

- The 'rectangular hardcovers': here are three really difficult ones with the notorious Black Hats ,

- The soft covers, where it is remarkable that the older ones (1950s) such as The Horns of the Rhinoceroses are more common than the more recent ones (early 1960s) such as The Gorilla Did It . And then you have The Nest of the Marsupilamis about which JozefK also said something.

Finally, it should also be mentioned that two versions of The Robbery of the Marsupilami and Spirou and the Heirs are known :
- With 'leather' spine and discoloration due to isinglass: Roof and Heirs
- With 'linen' spine without discolouration: Roof and Heirs
The history behind this is still unclear.

I satnd corrected ;-)

ie: I stand corrected ;-)

I have never been able to type

Aye aye Skkiper

Fijn zo Zwendel.

Heb je al rekening gehouden met deze informatie?

Je hebt daar nooit verder op gereageerd. Ik had graag jouw gedacht ook nog gehoord.

Well done Swindle.

Have you already taken this information into account?

You never responded to that. I would like to hear your thoughts as well.

I have now added it in the original post as well.

Whether one of the two is rarer is difficult to tell at the moment. Most users now of course still depend on the first version entered.

There should really be some system within Catawiki that alerts collectors and sellers when there are important updates to the catalog. There are analogous cases, for example The whip atom in original version and updated . I am almost certain that most collectors who meet the first print from reissue hang in reality have the second edition.

As for the Spiroues, I'm going to take a close look at my own specimens (unfortunately don't have them on hand this weekend).

eh you mean spirou's weekly or d'other comics

when weekly i am interested zziijjnn

ddaatt ssttaaaatt vvaasst

And to make it even more difficult ...

There are also two versions of 'De Zwarte Hoeden'.

With blue and white bracts.

25866 and 2220513

I see that you are experts in the field of first issues of Spirou.

I am looking for an adventure of Spirou in Anatolia and more specifically the discovery of Troy from the early 1960s or late 1960s 50.

Does anyone know what adventure this is?

To be honest, I have no idea.

Maybe you mean Uncle Wim in Spirou magazine?

112011

Yes, that's the adventure I'm looking for.

Does anyone know where I can find it?

Ik zou zeggen: in Robbedoes 1040.

I would say: in Spirou 1040 .

Strong work, book warehouse.

How nice to find something you are looking for for 1 euro!

Thank you Book Warehouse;)