Comic books/Personal Top 10 of all time51 messages

Always nice, to list your personal Top 10 of all time. This is mine:
1. Tintin in Tibet (Hergé)
2. Blake & amp; Mortimer: The Yellow Sign (Jacobs)
3. Isabelle and the Monster (Tardi)
4. The nest of the Marsupilamis (Franquin)
5. Fair of the Immortals (Bilal)
6. The village idiot of Schoonvergeten (Comès)
7. Hungarian Rhapsody (Giardino)
8. The beast is dead (Calvo). The original edition then with those fantastic colors.
9. Storm: The Last Fighter (Don Lawrence)
10. Heer Bommel and the top bosses (Toonder)
I am curious about your Top-10. Especially since your comic preferences also say something about yourself!

Phew, I just can't figure it out. But Tintin in Tibet and the Yellow sign are some kind of "bohemian rhapsody" that are brilliant.
Maybe you can think of a nice application to generate some sort of top 100 of all time.

Yes, that's a nice idea. We could offer the option to vote on an item. We will work out a little further.

Isabelle and the Monster and The Nest of the Marsupilamis are mainly in that place because of the impression they made on me when I first read them. Maybe there are better Tardi (Trench Warfare?) Or Franquin (QRN?) Albums if you organize a Top-100 election but these are my personal favorites.

Hello forummensae,
Nice idea that top 100… they have had one in Germany for a number of years too:
http://www.top100comics.de/comicvoting_internat ...
Maybe a guide?
Greetings,
René Visser

My personal top ten:
1-Sasmira-Call from the past
2-Arman and Ilva-the Perfect cycle
3-Secrets-Splinters
4-Tintin-Rocket to the moon, and men on the moon
5- The wind in the willows-the wild forest
6-Theodoor Cleysters-Rozendal
7-Ragebol- Sculptors of light
8-Kleine Robbe-Give a hand to madam!
9-Blunder- staggering revelations
10-The Vultures-For an apple and an EGG

PFffff, I really wouldn't know that right now.
I read so many comics, some stick around and some don't. In addition, I also read a lot of comics and mangas, I fear that I will no longer start to compile a top 10. What I really like is Thorgal, Franka, Deathnote, Golden city, Monster, S1ngle, well, I can go on for another hour… ..

Hello Scrooge,
Pffff… you are right… so difficult… now started with:
- The Killing Joke (Bolland)
- Douwe Dabbert
- Conan (Barry Windsor-Smith)
- XIII
But there is still so much.
Incidentally, I find it difficult to name individual albums… series is better off for me.
Greetings,
René Visser

ja, er wordt gesmokkeld hé,zo kan ik het ook ;-) Maar er zit wel iets in dat wat je leest iets zegt over wie je bent. Vooruit dan, een top-5:
1 Koos Voos, Gotlib (nou ja stiekum het hele oeuvre van Gotlib)
2 Kuifje: Eenhoorn + schat (eigenlijk één verhaal)
3 Asterix en Cleopatra (en de rest van de reeks toen Goscinny er nog was)
4 Het Gele teken Blake en Mortimer
5 Horizon (Lian Ong)
Oei, Koos Voos op één. Wat zou mijn psychiater daar van zeggen…

yes, there is smuggling hey, that's how I can do it ;-) But there is something in it that what you read says something about who you are. Come on then, a top-5:
1 Koos Voos, Gotlib (well, secretly Gotlib's entire oeuvre)
2 Tintin: Unicorn + Treasure (actually one story)
3 Asterix And Cleopatra (And The Rest Of The Series When Goscinny Was Still Around)
4 The Yellow Mark Blake and Mortimer
5 Horizon (Lian Ong)
Oops, Koos Voos on one. What would my psychiatrist say about that…

But there is something in what you read says something about who you are.
1 Koos Voos, Gotlib
hahaha!

3 Asterix and Cleopatra
Don't you like the First Legion better? I should have put it in my top-10 ...

Rene,
it's whether the devil is playing. I reread it yesterday! Yes, it is great. I actually love everything about Asterix.

Good he is. Especially Tennis of course!

Just started cataloging here and still go through the forum items. haha, nice subject, which I also like to pick up on.
My personal top ten looks like this:
1. Trench Warfare (Tardi)
2. Ibiscus (Rabaté), the cycle as a whole
3. L'ascencion du haut mal (David B.), also the entire series
4. le cri du peuple (Tardi), as a whole
5. Jimmy Corrigan, the smartest kid on earth (Chris Ware)
6. Ici Même (Tardi)
7. The Chinkel (Rosinski)
8. L'autoroute du soleil (Baru)
9. Buddha (Tezuka), as a whole
10. Eva (Comès)
Actually, I would like to continue with that list. There is still so much that is not to be sneezed at either and is one of my favorites.
That there is so much French in it, I can't help it. Bilingual Fleming isn't it…
And finally: it is not too obvious that I am a big tardiphile :) :) ??
gr, Michkepee

Welcome to the Michkepee forum!
Nice choices. Although I did not know the word yet, I must confess that I am also a Tardifiel. I chose Isabelle over Trench Warfare (also impressive of course!) Because I was the first Tardi comic to read and it made a big impression. I find your choice for Eva instead of the village idiot of Schoonvergeten surprising. Will Eva reread again. I am a monolingual Dutch person so I do not venture French yet :-) Le cri du peuple has been translated (Voice of the people).
If you've got the hang of it, feel free to continue after 10. I'm curious about your Top-100 :-)

A very obvious number one, I know. And that “Le cri” can also be translated and especially read, is not unknown to me either, because it is also in my possession (just take a look at my collection).
I have been “Tardifiel” for a long time. I got that virus through the magazine “Wordt Vervolgd”, which unfortunately passed away much too quickly. Fortunately there was “A Suivre” that unfortunately no longer exists.
Because you ask it so beautifully: hereafter the following ten:
11. Letters from the bar (Stassen)
12. Brüsel (Schuiten / Peeters)
13. l'Homme qui marche (Taniguchi)
14. Life is a gift but you will not get it (Seth)
15. Quartier lointain (Taniguchi)
16. Persepolis (Satrapi)
17. Maus (Spiegelman)
18. La débauche / the degradation (Tardi)
19. Deadly Games (Tardi)
20. Niçoise salad (Baudoin).
Another few Tardis. And also some poetic comics, which really appeal to me, such as almost everything by Taniguchi (unfortunately not much available in translation).
The village idiot (Comès) is also not bad, of course, far from it.
While compiling this list, I am concerned that there is an urgent need to reread some things :-).
gr, Michkepee

I just signed up and since I love lists, here's my version:
1. The incal (the complete original series; all spin-offs are unnecessary in my opinion)
2. Corto Maltese in Siberia (actually the whole series, but I have to choose ...)
3. Blueberry - Angel Face
4. Comanche - The Wolves of Wyoming
5. The Man Without Conscience (Hugo Pratt)
6. Indian Summer (both parts; 1 story)
7. Eva (I also choose this story from Comès in the end)
8. Indian series - The way of revenge - 9. Tintin - The 7 Crystal Balls
10. Suske en Wiske - The Tuf-Tuf club
The list may already indicate that I am a collector of Western and Indian comics. I also keep track of the work of Hugo Pratt, Comès and the collaboration between Renaud and Dufaux. And now that I say this, I realize that Santiaq would not be out of place in this list.

Nice list! I completely forgot about the Incal. It should have been in my top 10, actually. And Hermann also misses me now (surprising that you choose Comanche by the way). Hmmm… I have to make a top 20 soon.
@ michkepee: I should have thought of Maus myself of course. By the way, where's your top 50? :-)

@ René: that is just soooooo terribly difficult after those first 20…
I will on occasion thoroughly delve into my collection and then knit a sequel to that top 20.
Greetings and have a nice weekend. michkepee

I am very curious, you can also post your top 100 per 10 :-)

top 10 top 100
read and own so many good ones
will one day include them in the list

I will certainly forget a few but here my current personal TOP 20 preferences, possibly in no particular order .. and of course all other albums from those series ...
01. Ebony Scam and Rebellion in Jamaica (Redbeard 21 and 24 / Pellerin)
02. The Archer (Thorgal 9 / Rosinski)
03. Chninkel (Rosinski)
04. Angel face, (Blueberry 18 / Giraud) - 05. The Last Fighter (Storm 2 / Don.L)
06. Wolf Child (Legend 1 / Swolfs)
07. Uncle Scrooge McDuck Young Years series (Don Rosa)
08. Lynx Guardian (Lotus flower 7 / Franz)
09. The Heir (Largo Winch / Francq)
10. Seasick (Pacush Blues / Ptluc)
11. Purple and Gold (Murena / Delaby)
12. Beyond the boundaries of time (Pont)
13. Tarzan Classics 237-241 (Manning)
14. Alex the Intrepid (J. Martin)
15. Mercenaries (Jeremiah 20 / Hermann)
16. Blacksad 1 (Guarnido / canales)
17. The Hunter (Tijdvogel / Loisel)
18. Indian summer (Manara) - 19. Lady in Blue (Bilal)
20. Heart for Iceland 1 & amp; 2 (Makyo)

Leuk, lijstjes
Top twintig stripmakers
1. Robert Crumb
2. Tardi
3. Hugo Pratt
4. Hergé
5. Chris Ware
6. Franquin
7. Winsor McCay
8. George Herriman
9. Patrick McDonall
10. Carl Barks
11. Will Eisner
12. Joost Swarte
13. Jaime Hernandez
14. Jim Woodring
15. Peter Pontiac
16. Bernard Krigstein
17. Edgar P. Jacobs
18. Daniel Clowes
19. Martin Lodewijk
20. Marc Smeets

Nice lists
Top twenty comic creators
1.Robert Crumb
2. Tardy
3. Hugo Pratt
4. Herge
5. Chris Ware
6. Franklin
7. Winsor McCay
8.George Herriman
9.Patrick McDonall
10.Carl Barks
11. Will Eisner
12. Joost Black
13.Jaime Hernandez
14.Jim Woodring
15. Peter Pontiac
16.Bernard Krigstein
17. Edgar P. Jacobs
18.Daniel Clowes
19. Martin Louis
20. Marc Smeets

Wow, great list! Right place for Tardi. Only I would put Hergé on 1 anyway. And Franquin on 3.

difficult. may also change it at some point. but go ahead.
1.Batman: Dark victory.
2. Trench warfare. Tardi
3.Punisher max vol.5 the Slavers
4.Meccano the Rough guide
5.the Adventures of Julius Antoine. Lea
6.th Killer. Jacamon and Matz
7.Green manor part.1
8.o dear I don't remember, no asterix and no freak broters, did I have to put the teeth of the shark in it or something from Micheluzzi or Pratt. how difficult, maybe just put madness-madness on nine and ten. I also enjoyed Thomas Noland and Frank Cappa. I'm just going to start on my top 100, but then I can't read anything in between. aaaaaaarg